MLB The Show 25is already shaping up to be one of the best in the franchise, with fans eager to make their playthroughs the best they can be.From the meta-breaking hittersto the game-saving defenders, there is something for everyone, and there are players that most fans are going to want on their squad.
Ratings are based on skill set as well as OVR (overall rating), to make sure that both the veterans of the sport and the rising talents are recognized. While we know how much fame and real-life performances affect players, the in-game impact is the strongest hit.
10Francisco Lindor – SS, New York Mets (89 OVR)
Top-Tier Shortstop
Francisco has good power vs LHP, and his fielding stats at the top make him a very reliable glove. His durable and quick reactions will help any player looking for someone strong on their team, and his smooth and steady swing will be something to be remembered.
Players will be in great hands having Francisco as part of their team, as he is one of the best defensively-focused middle infielders. However,what he demonstrates as a great teamplayer Shortstopcannot make up for the lack of elite offense, which some players are looking for.
9Mookie Betts – SS (2B, RF), Los Angeles Dodgers (91 OVR)
Versatility Redefined
Mookie is a flexible player across both infield and outfield. His balanced hitting, combined with a strong clutch, makes him a top pick for players. He is the kind of player who excels in long Franchise runs, and one to watch out for if a fan plays against him.
Unfortunately, Mookie lacks that raw power that some of the other players have and could be seen as more of a support player than someone who is a main carry for the team. However, he is still an extremely useful and budget-friendly player to have, so players maywant to start building up their stubs.
8Bryce Harper – 1B, Philadelphia Phillies (92 OVR)
Position Versatility
Bryce is one of the most perfect picks for competitive matches because of that almost perfect high clutch rating. He has great power vs RHP, and the 1B opens new lineup options that would be available to players. His buy price is also solid for a great contact player, compared to some of the higher sold players on the list.
Bryce does have some limitations when it comes to fielding and position shift, which is what leaves him out of top spots. He is more of a niche pick than anything else, but he holds strong value to players even without the top power hitter skills.
7José Ramírez – 3B, Cleveland Guardians (93 OVR)
The Consistent Producer
José is a very durable player, good for bothRoad To The Show position changes where neededand Franchise playthroughs. He is a switch hitter with strong all-field contact, making him a smooth and stable 3B. If players are looking to head a competitive lineup, José would be a great choice for his consistency.
While José could be a top pick for some players, he does miss out on a top spot for not having a clear standout elite trait. He is reliable and widely usable as a player, but some players looking for someone with one elite stat may want to look at some of the next higher-ranking picks.
6Mike Trout – RF (LF, CF), Los Angeles Angels (86 OVR)
Veteran Excellence
Mike’s a very useful pick when it comes to Diamond Dynasty and still has a high Power Right even as time has passed. His hits are fast and reliable, perfect for any player looking for consistency in their team. Mike’s leadership quirks and overall rating make him one of the best picks for any player. Those veteran skills go a long way.
His OVR has lowered due to age decline and stat drop. While Mike may have missed out on some of the top spots, he is still an iconic and consistent player, one that any fan of the game would be grateful to have on their team.
5Ketel Marte – 2B (SS, CF), Arizona Diamondbacks (93 OVR)
Best Breakout In Season
Ketel is such a versatile player across multiple positions and is on the most budget-friendly side whenplayers are looking to build up their teams. He has great contact vs LHP, and with an above-average speed swing, players will have a lot of fun playing with Ketel.
His ranking is based on his more balanced stats, and not something so extreme. Ketel is a solid option for any player, but does lack the elite power or specialization that some people may prefer in team members. However, Ketel is a great pick for those players looking to have flexibility.
4Juan Soto – RF (LF), New York Mets (94 OVR)
Exceptional Plate Discipline
Juan’s durability attribute ensures that he is a long-term value for Franchise, and his massive PCI size is helpful when it comes to timing. The high vision and discipline that he has makes at-bats so much easier compared to other players, and that hitter total is something to be admired.
Juan couldn’t make it to the top 3 due to his lower defensive value, but his outfield arm and speed are elite, which puts him high on the list. With a 94 OVR and impressive stats, Juan is still a must-have when it comes to a bat with a consistent offensive presence.
3Bobby Witt Jr. – SS, Kansas City Royals (100 OVR)
A Dynamic Talent
Bobby’s speed and power combo is rare for SS, which is what makes him so valuable to players. Bobby is the perfect team member for both aggressive base-running and defensive SS options.And that hitter total is somethingthat even other players would struggle to keep up with.
Bobby is the only player in this ranking with an over 100 OVR score, showcasing his well-rounded attributes and talent. While some fans may be surprised by seeing Bobby so high up in the ranking, his in-game performance is something to celebrate compared to him getting overshadowed in real life sometimes.
2Aaron Judge – RF (LF, CF), New York Yankees (95 OVR)
Powerhouse Hitter
Aaron has massive home run potential, especially for players looking to compete in online matches against others. That high discipline score also makes PCI a little more forgiving. If players are looking for someone to come in the clutch in those late-inning scenarios, Aaron is one of the best bets.
Aaron couldn’t get the top spot due to that lack of versatility, but this is made up for due to his reliable bat and clutch skills. He is one of the most valuable players that a fan of the game could have on their team, and with a 95 overall rating, it’s hard to compare Aaron to others.
1Shohei Ohtani – SP(RF), Los Angeles Dodgers (92 OVR)
The True Two-Way Star
If players are looking for the top hitter and pitcher card, look no further than Shohei. Because of his unique and strong 2-way stats, he is elite and a great all-rounder for any player’s team. Shohei has a rare versatility with solid control and power vs RHP and will help carry both offense and pitching.
Shohei is still at the top of this list despite his overall score going down due to injury, as his versatility is unmatched. While the pitcher total brings the OVR down, too, there are not many other players who can match his skill set,but the Submarine pitchers have potential.
