Squishmallows, these huggable plushie havens of comfort from Original Squishmallows, seem to be on their way to forming an ever-expanding universe of their own. If you have a friend who enjoys the sense of home that these plush toys are always ready to share, chances are thatthere is a Squishmallow to celebrate your friendship.
On the flip side, finding your favorite fantasy creature among thousands of different Squishmallows is like trying to find a one-of-a-kind plushie in a pile of plush toys. With how many of these creatures lean more on the side of rarity, the hunt for these little squishable collectibles becomes the definition of a rough deal.
Luckily, there are some mythical plush wonders on this list that might help make the search easier for plushie lovers. Some are certainly rarer than others, but let’s face it – this only adds to what makes them truly legendary creatures in the Squishmallow form. Like theamazing Pokemon Squishmallow plush toysthat have recently been on sale, they seem to never lose their charm.
No doubt, those who love the fantasy genre have quite a fewSquishmallow plush toys inspired by Disney charactersto explore already. Some fans, however, may want more unique fantasy creature friends in their collections. Without further ado, let’s see what Original Squishmallows has in store for them.
7Romano The Hippocampus Squishmallow
Romano’s Squishdate: 21-05-2025
If there is someone who knows how to relax and unwind, it has to be the super-chill Romano. This blue hippocampus is a fantasy creature involved in various myths about the sea. This seaweed-farming Squishmallow comes in the appearance of a half-horse and a half-fish, and it attracts the eyes and hearts of fans no less than its more extroverted counterpart, Quayn.
The cuteness of Romano can be grasped in three sizes: 5 inches, 8 inches, and 16 inches. Though his tag suggests that he is not among rare collectibles, that doesn’t make the squishiness of Romano any less lovable. Sadly, his smaller 5-inch version may not be easy to track down anymore. With that said, fans can stillget theless elusive8-inch and 16-inch Romano the Hippocampus Squishmallowson Amazon.
6Ambergris The Goblin King Squishmallow
Ambergris’s Squishdate: 27-05-2025
Long live the cuteness of the king – the Goblin King of Squishmallows. Gracing fans with his very presence, Ambergris is a mighty goblin who knows a thing or two about collections, especially the little porcelain pig ones. His royally squishable highness Ambergris comes with an escort of a few fellow goblins that fans may also adore: Chitra, Fitzy, Soupy, and Felipe. In case you feel right at home when playinggames that nurture your inner loot goblin, this plush toy can be no less than your totem creature.
At the moment, Ambergris comes inone sizeonly: 16 inches. His tag has himmarked as ultra rare, which means that there are only 50,000 Goblin Kings in existence. Hopefully, this giant Squishmallow gets to complete his collections in time before fans carry him off to grace other collections and adventures with the cuteness of this squishable sovereign.
5Ernest The Monster Squishmallow
Ernest’s Squishdate: 22-05-2025
As a fantasy creature of spooky proportions, Ernest is a lot more than what he appears to be at first glance. This big orange fellow has an unmatched love for hot chocolate. He also enjoys playing tic-tac-toe with his many fellow monster friends. In fact, his Halloween squad has quite a few fun collectible treats to offer that make for perfect additions to manycute Squishmallows and plush toys for spooky occasions.
Currently, Ernestis available in several sizes: 4.5 inches, 10 inches, and 12 inches. He is also huggable in its cute 3.5-inch clip-on form. Speaking of forms, Ernest has the aura of a true Halloween monster in his 12-inch Candy Apple version back from the 2024 spooky season. For now, fans can tap intomostofErnest’sversionson Amazon.
4Analea The Caticorn Squishmallow
Analea’s Squishdate: 11-07-2025
While unicorns might be the most recognizable fantasy creatures to charm us, cats are the most recognizable tricksters to draw us into fantasies of their own. Original Squishmallows has decided to morph the magic of both these creatures into one – the caticorn.
With her curiosity about earthquakes, one could say that sweet Analea has distinctly more feline features. At the same time, the satisfaction she gains from being a geologist brings out her unicorn side in many ways. In fact, the inquisitive nature of this Squishmallow plushie and the charm ofcute cat-themed board gamesseem like a match made in heaven. The best part is that this cat-unicorn hybrid is not alone, as there are more collectible caticorn friends to add to the colorful clowder-herd.
The charm of this fun mythical hybrid can be squished intwo sizes: 14 inches and 16 inches. Both sizes of this little tabby-unicorn creature are easy to find on Amazon.
3Theotto The Cthulhu Squishmallow
Theotto’s Squishdate: 21-07-2025
Being a horror haunting others solely with its cuteness and squishability, Theotto the Cthulhu is a fantasy creature that many fans wouldn’t want to miss out on. While he may hibernate for most of the year, this little mythical creature is more than happy to come out to say hello when the weather feels right. More so, this marsh-dwelling Squishmallow has a few Cthulhu friends for you to meet during the next autumn festival.
Fresh out of his hibernation, Theotto can be spotted in a variety of sizes: 5 inches, 7.5 inches, 8 inches, 10 inches, and 12 inches. He also fits into a 3.5-inch clip-on form. This Lovecraftian monster, though, exists in another Squishmallow form as well, namely as a 12-inch Pumpkin Frappuccino version from Halloween back in 2024. Today, fans canget him in his 10-inch form on Amazon.
2Shasta The Bigfoot Squishmallow
Shasta’s Squishdate: 30-06-2025
In color and personality alike, Shasta is the epitome of a peachy Squishmallow. This adorable Bigfoot showcases her cheery presence with skills in hospitality and hotel management. If one is ever on the lookout for the best beach view, this fantasy creature will know exactly what to recommend. She also makes for a perfect companion if you love playinghorror games that are set in the woods. Thankfully, she isn’t the only Bigfoot sighting that Squishmallow fans are in for, as there are many more lurking around.
The Bigfoot magic of Shasta lives in two sizes: 5 inches and 12 inches. Additionally, this peachy character hides in a few other forms, namely Shasta Hoodie and the regular clip-on form. Fans can also get her in a wholenewselect seriesexclusiveform–8-inch scented Mango Boba– on the official Original Squishmallows website. For the time being,Amazon has the regular 12-inch Shasta the Bigfootready to be squished.
1Golden Dragon Squishmallow
Golden Dragon Squishdate: Unknown
No list of fantasy creatures would be complete without at least one dragon. In the Squishmallow universe, one can come across some absolutely charming dragon species, such asthe gorgeous Dragonite Squishmallow. Within the scope of this list, though, there is one more dragon species on Squishmallow ranges waiting to be snagged. It’s the8-inch Golden Dragonavailable asa select seriescollectible.
Without a doubt, dragons are creatures of mystery. AsHouse of the DragonSeason 3 prepares surprises, so does the Golden Dragon Squishmallow have quite a surprise in store for its fans. Besides its rarity, this little fantasy beast comes with a special code for a redeemable virtual item inAdopt Me!
